Tech firms and telecom operators are facing off over steep SMS tariffs, causing one-time passcodes and messages to consumers from abroad to cost several times more than what they cost domestically. In response to a consultation paper by the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI), telcos argued that there was no need to change the definition of ‘international traffic,’ a key term that determines what an international SMS is, and by extension, what it should cost.
The Cellular Operators Association of India (COAI) painted companies that routed SMS messages through domestic gateways as getting away from “having to pay the international SMS termination charge,” an expensive add-on to SMS tariffs to deliver text messages from abroad.
How expensive? “International SMS is a lucrative market,” Nitin Singhal, the India Managing Director for Sinch, a firm that provides text communications services to global brands, told The Hindu. “Rates can be 30 times higher than domestic tariffs.” That comes out to ₹1.50 per text, which can work out to an astronomical figure when enterprises are sending out vast volumes of one-time passcodes.
All this while SMS remains an extremely inexpensive service for telecom operators. The disconnect between the price and the cost was most evident when Nigel Bannister, a professor at the University of Leicester, was able to calculate in 2008 that it was less expensive to download data from the Hubble Space Telescope to earth than it was to send an SMS message in that year’s tariffs in the UK.
The Broadband India Forum, which represents Big Tech firms like Amazon and Google as well as Internet Service Providers, argued that insisting on strict geographical boundaries for SMS was inappropriate when it was possible to send an SMS message over the internet to an Indian gateway. “[T]he excesses of international SMS pricing have little to nothing to do with cost of providing service,” BIF said in its filing.
Costly international SMS pricing can also lead to fraud, Mr. Singhal of Sinch pointed out. Firms that use SMS to verify international users have to pay the telco that ultimately delivers the SMS. After Elon Musk took over the social media platform Twitter, he alleged that telecom operators around the world were defrauding the firm of $60 million a year by creating bot accounts that requested bogus SMS OTPs from Twitter, for which the company had to pay.
“I said, cut off any telco that’s got fraud above 10 percent,” Mr. Musk said in an online discussion in January. This coincides with a period where Twitter stopped delivering SMS messages to Reliance Jio and Bharti Airtel customers.
Read the article on The Hindu.
When you visit any website, it may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. This information might be about you, your preferences or your device and is mostly used to make the site work as you expect it to. The information does not usually directly identify you, but it can give you a more personalized web experience.
Because we respect your right to privacy, you can choose not to allow some types of cookies. Click on the different category headings to find out more and change our default settings. However, blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience of the site and the services we are able to offer.
Cookie Statement
These cookies are necessary for the website to function and cannot be switched off in our systems. They are usually only set in response to actions made by you which amount to a request for services, such as setting your privacy preferences, logging in or filling in forms. You can set your browser to block or alert you about these cookies, but some parts of the site will not then work.
These cookies do not store any personally identifiable information.
Cookie details
Cookie Subgroup | Cookies | Cookies used |
---|---|---|
eu5.mm.sdi.sinch.com | ASP.NET_SessionId | First Party |
community.sinch.com | AWSALB , LiSESSIONID | First Party |
appengage.sinch.com | dd_cookie_test_ | First Party |
tickets.sinch.com | atlassian.xsrf.token , JSESSIONID | First Party |
cockpit2.sinch.com | SESSION | First Party |
engage.sinch.com | instapage-variant-xxxxxxxx | First Party |
dashboard.sinch.com | cookietest | First Party |
brand.sinch.com | PHPSESSID , AWSALBCORS | First Party |
sinch.com | __cf_bm , OptanonConsent , TEST_AMCV_COOKIE_WRITE , OptanonAlertBoxClosed , onesaasCookieSettings, QueryString, functional-cookies, performance-cookies, targeting-cookies, social-cookies lastExternalReferrer, lastExternalReferrertime, cookies, receive-cookie-deprecation _gdvisitor, _gd_session, _gcl_au, _fbp, _an_uid, _utm_zzses, lpv | First Party |
mediabrief.com | __cf_bm | Third Party |
recaptcha.net | _GRECAPTCHA | Third Party |
cision.com | __cf_bm | Third Party |
techtarget.com | __cf_bm | Third Party |
These cookies allow us to count visits and traffic sources so we can measure and improve the performance of our site. They help us to know which pages are the most and least popular and see how visitors move around the site. All information these cookies collect is aggregated and therefore anonymous.
If you do not allow these cookies we will not know when you have visited our site, and will not be able to monitor its performance.
Cookie details
Cookie Subgroup | Cookies | Cookies used |
---|---|---|
community.sinch.com | ValueSurveyVisitorCount | First Party |
buzz.sinch.com | instap-spid.8069 , instap-spses.8069 | First Party |
appengage.sinch.com | _dd_s | First Party |
sinch.com | AMP_TLDTEST , rl_page_init_referrer , rl_trait , _vis_opt_s , __q_state_dp56h9oqwhna9CoL , cb_user_id , __hstc , rl_anonymous_id , rl_user_id , initialTrafficSource , _vwo_uuid , _vwo_uuid_v2 , rl_page_init_referring_domain , _hjIncludedInSessionSample_xxx , apt.uid , __hssrc , test_rudder_cookie , cb%3Atest , __hssc , rl_group_trait , _hjAbsoluteSessionInProgress , _vwo_referrer , _vwo_sn , _vis_opt_test_cookie , _hjFirstSeen , _hjTLDTest , _hjSession_xxxxxx , s_sq , _vwo_ds , rl_group_id , _vis_opt_exp_n_combi , s_cc , _gclxxxx , cb_anonymous_id , cb_group_id , apt.sid , rl_session , _uetvid , AMP_899c7e29a9 , _hjSessionUser_xxxxxx | First Party |
brand.sinch.com | AMP_TEST | First Party |
engage.sinch.com | no-cache , instap-spses.85bb , instap-spid.85bb | First Party |
www.sinch.com | d-a8e6 , s-9da4 | First Party |
nr-data.net | JSESSIONID | Third Party |
sinch-en.newsroom.cision.com | _ga, _gid | Third Party |
sinch.in | _ga_xxxxxxxxxx, _gat_UA-XXXXXX-X, _gid, _ga | Third Party |
terminus.services | terminustb | Third Party |
g.fastcdn.co | instap-spses.85bb | Third Party |
hello.learn.mailjet.com | pardot, visitor_id, visitor_id##### | Third Party |
www.googletagmanager.com | userId | Third Party |
hello.learn.mailgun.com | visitor_id#####, visitor_id | Third Party |
dev.visualwebsiteoptimizer.com | _vwo_ssm | Third Party |
box.com | box_visitor_id | Third Party |
app.box.com | z, cn | Third Party |
sinch-tfn.paperform.co | laravel_session | Third Party |
go.sinch.in | visitor_id#####, visitor_id | Third Party |
Qualified | __q_local_form_debug | Third party |
Rudderstack | rudder.inProgress, rudder.3156dd1f-7029-4600-ae54-baf147d9af20.queue, rudder.3156dd1f-7029-4600-ae54-baf147d9af20.ack, rudder.3156dd1f-7029-4600-ae54-baf147d9af20.reclaimStart, rudder.3156dd1f-7029-4600-ae54-baf147d9af20.reclaimEnd, | Third party |
6sense | _6senseCompanyDetauls, _6signalTTL | Third party |
Appcues | apc_local_id, apc_user | Third party |
These cookies may be set through our site by our advertising partners. They may be used by those companies to build a profile of your interests and show you relevant adverts on other sites. They do not store directly personal information, but are based on uniquely identifying your browser and internet device.
If you do not allow these cookies, you will experience less targeted advertising.
Cookie details
Cookie Subgroup | Cookies | Cookies used |
---|---|---|
investors.sinch.com | visitor_id | First Party |
community.sinch.com | VISITOR_BEACON , LithiumVisitor | First Party |
sinch.com | _uetsid , ajs_user_id , _gcl_aw , ajs_group_id , AMCV_ , __utmzzses , _fbp , _gcl_au , AMCVS_ | First Party |
go.latam.sinch.com | visitor_id##### , pardot | First Party |
linkedin.com | li_gc, bcookie, lidc, AnalyticsSyncHistory, UserMatchHistory, li_sugr | Third Party |
pi.pardot.com | lpv151751, pardot | Third Party |
hsforms.com | _cfuvid | Third Party |
google.com | CONSENT | Third Party |
sinch.in | _gclxxxx, _gcl_au | Third Party |
www.linkedin.com | bscookie | Third Party |
bing.com | MUID, MSPTC | Third Party |
www.facebook.com | Third Party | |
hello.learn.mailgun.com | pardot | Third Party |
www.youtube.com | TESTCOOKIESENABLED | Third Party |
dev.visualwebsiteoptimizer.com | uuid | Third Party |
g2crowd.com | __cf_bm | Third Party |
pardot.com | visitor_id#####, visitor_id | Third Party |
tracking.g2crowd.com | _session_id | Third Party |
hubspot.com | __cf_bm, _cfuvid | Third Party |
doubleclick.net | test_cookie, IDE | Third Party |
youtube.com | CONSENT, VISITOR_PRIVACY_METADATA, VISITOR_INFO1_LIVE | Third Party |
go.sinch.in | pardot | Third Party |
liadm.com | lidid | Third Party |
www.google.com | _GRECAPTCHA | Third Party |
These cookies enable the website to provide enhanced functionality and personalisation. They may be set by us or by third party providers whose services we have added to our pages. If you do not allow these cookies, then some or all of these services may not function properly.
Cookie details
Cookie Subgroup | Cookies | Cookies used |
---|---|---|
portal.sinch.com | pnctest | First Party |
partner.appengage.sinch.com | _dd_s | First Party |
investors.sinch.com | First Party | |
community.sinch.com | LithiumUserInfo , LithiumUserSecure | First Party |
tickets.sinch.com | selectedidp | First Party |
engage.sinch.com | ln_or | First Party |
cockpit2.sinch.com | CSRF-TOKEN , NG_TRANSLATE_LANG_KEY | First Party |
sinch.com | apt.temp-xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx , hubspotutk , ajs%3Acookies , cf_clearance , ajs%3Atest , __tld__ , __q_domainTest , pfjs%3Acookies , ajs_anonymous_id | First Party |
auth.appengage.sinch.com | AUTH_SESSION_ID , KEYCLOAK_3P_COOKIE , KEYCLOAK_3P_COOKIE_SAMESITE , KC_RESTART , AUTH_SESSION_ID_LEGACY | First Party |
www.recaptcha.net | _GRECAPTCHA | Third Party |
boxcdn.net | __cf_bm | Third Party |
d2oeshgsx64tgz.cloudfront.net | cookietest | Third Party |
sinch-np.paperform.co | XSRF-TOKEN, laravel_session | Third Party |
vimeo.com | __cf_bm, vuid | Third Party |
sinch-ca-sc.paperform.co | XSRF-TOKEN, laravel_session | Third Party |
box.com | site_preference | Third Party |
app.box.com | bv | Third Party |
sinch-tfn.paperform.co | XSRF-TOKEN | Third Party |
cision.com | cf_clearance | Third Party |
These cookies are set by a range of social media services that we have added to the site to enable you to share our content with your friends and networks. They are capable of tracking your browser across other sites and building up a profile of your interests. This may impact the content and messages you see on other websites you visit. If you do not allow these cookies you may not be able to use or see these sharing tools.
Cookie details
Cookie Subgroup | Cookies | Cookies used |
---|---|---|
community.sinch.com | ln_or | First Party |
sinch.in | _fbp | Third Party |
youtube-nocookie.com | CONSENT | Third Party |
youtube.com | YSC | Third Party |